---
title: "The wonderful, horrible life of User Generated Content"
id: "2402"
type: "post"
slug: "the-wonderful-horrible-life-of-user-generated-content"
published_at: "2010-11-24T10:00:10+00:00"
modified_at: "2010-11-24T10:00:10+00:00"
url: "https://www.cherryleaf.com/2010/11/the-wonderful-horrible-life-of-user-generated-content/"
markdown_url: "https://www.cherryleaf.com/2010/11/the-wonderful-horrible-life-of-user-generated-content.md"
excerpt: "User Generated Content (UGC), that is user documentation written by users, is growing trend in the world of technical communication. However, although there are enormous benefits from UGC, we’ve found it can lead users to miss professionally written user documentation...."
taxonomy_category:
  - "Technical Documentation"
  - "trends"
  - "UGC"
  - "user generated content"
  - "user manuals"
taxonomy_post_tag:
  - "information design"
  - "trends"
  - "usability"
  - "user generated content"
---

User Generated Content (UGC), that is user documentation written by users, is growing trend in the world of technical communication. However, although there are enormous benefits from UGC, we’ve found it can lead users to miss professionally written user documentation. The consequence of this can be that users search and navigate down blind allies in a search for useful and relevant information.

So is UGC creating a scotoma, or tunnel vision, in the mind of the users?

### Let’s look at an example

[This blog](http://blogs.atlassian.com/developer/2009/04/setting_up_jira_and_confluence.html)
, by one software vendor, describes a solution for how organisation can host its own powerful content management system “in the cloud” for peanuts. It comes with disclaimers that this is not supported officially by the vendor, but there’s evidence it is possible. Via the comments at the end of the blog post, you’ll discover the original solution has been superseded, but the writer has helpfully provided a rough outline on the best way to do it today.

So the curious user is sent off on a quest to find the complete answer.

The first stop on this quest is the links in the article itself. Because the solution is not supported officially, in this example, the linked pages do not provide the full answer.

So what does the user do next? We found, in most cases, their second step will be to search on Google and see if the solution has been provided anywhere else. In this example, it will lead them to blog articles written by a variety of different people and organisations. [This article, by Phil Paradis](http://library.linode.com/web-applications/wikis/confluence/fedora-13)
, for example, provides his solution to the problem.

We found the a key problem with the user generated content in the scenario above, it wasn’t clear whether the advice was still valid or not. A user could spend a great deal of time diving into the murky depths of Linux terminal commands, only to discover eventually that the hosting software part of the solution had been updated to be more user-friendly. What’s more, it now came with [very clear user assistance](http://docs.amazonwebservices.com/AWSEC2/latest/GettingStartedGuide/)
.

### Why are users going towards the unofficial documentation?

There are a number of possible reasons why users are more likely to be ending up looking at the unofficial rather than official documentation:

- The user starts by reading a blog and expects the answer to also be in a blog. The reader has created a scotoma in their mind.
- The search terms entered by the user into Google are more likely to lead them to unofficial content than official content.
- Because the solution is not supported officially, the official documentation does not provide information on this topic.
- The official user documentation is not ranked highly by Google.
- The official user documentation has been poorly written, in comparison to the unofficial content.

### What is the solution?

A lot of software solutions are based on integrating a number of applications and services together, and it’s not uncommon for people to be looking for the type of answer outlined in the example above.

As there are a number of reasons why the problem may occur, so there are a number of possible solutions:

- The official user documentation needs to be findable via Google. If users begin their quest by searching, then they are likely to continue to use that approach.
- Present professional user documentation and user generated content in the same system. If they begin by following links, then they likely to continue using that approach. If we can guide users to professional user documentation, with all the version control and provenance information it usually contains, at the right time, then we may be able to combine the best of both types of user documentation.
- Engage with the bloggers via the comments to provide links back to the official documentation.
- Consider the search terms users might enter and provide information that will appear high in the rankings. This may involve creating pages on topics that are not supported officially and contain a number of caveats.

We welcome your thoughts and comments.

### Share this:

- [Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook](https://www.cherryleaf.com/2010/11/the-wonderful-horrible-life-of-user-generated-content/?share=facebook)
- [Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn](https://www.cherryleaf.com/2010/11/the-wonderful-horrible-life-of-user-generated-content/?share=linkedin)
- [Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp](https://www.cherryleaf.com/2010/11/the-wonderful-horrible-life-of-user-generated-content/?share=jetpack-whatsapp)
- [Share on Bluesky (Opens in new window) Bluesky](https://www.cherryleaf.com/2010/11/the-wonderful-horrible-life-of-user-generated-content/?share=bluesky)
-

### *Related*

### 6 Comments

[…] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Ian Truscott, Ellis Pratt, Ellis Pratt, S. Kleineikenscheidt, Kai Weber and others. Kai Weber said: via @ellispratt: The wonderful, horrible life of User Generated Content [http://is.gd/hGUl1](http://is.gd/hGUl1)
 < insightful description of mixed blessings! […]

These are some great tips for handling UGC. In case it might be helpful, I thought I’d send a link to the transcripts for the #tcchat about Managing and Integrating UGC, which was held in October. There are some links to examples and discussion about various aspects of working with UGC. Here’s the link: [http://www.2morodocs.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/101021_UGC1.htm](http://www.2morodocs.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/101021_UGC1.htm)
. Hope that helps! Also, an upcoming session in December will be about Search and SEO.

Hallo Ellis

This is a thought-provoking post! Many of us are grappling with UGC. I’d even say that all of us are grappling with it, but some of us just don’t know that yet. 🙂 The fact is that users will go and search Google to find the answers to their questions. If they don’t find our documentation first, they will find other information first. For that reason, I think the first and last of your bullet points under “What is the solution?” are the most important: SEO of our documentation. The first criterion is then that the documentation must be online and open for all to see.

Another solution is to go where the users are and see what they’re asking. They’re all over the place, in Twitter, forums, Facebook, blogs and other types of online communities. Of course, there just aren’t enough technical writers to monitor all those locations and also write the docs. What we need is some tool that searches the web for relevant comments/topics and alerts us when they come in. Google Alerts may be part of the solution, but I don’t think there’s a complete one anywhere yet.

Does anyone have any ideas in that area?

Cheers  
 Sarah

Thanks Sarah. I agree. Ian Truscott (@IanTruscott) commented on Twitter that Technical Authors may need to develop a social media strategy.

The example I cited related to integrating two applications and this is often, when it comes to support and documentation, where cracks appear.

[…] “The Wonderful, Horrible Life of User Generated Content,” Ellis Pratt discusses the trend of users coming upon unofficial documentation. Reasons for […]

In my current workplace, we have received a request to do more “external learning” which lends credence to what Sarah says about the need to go where users go. Keeping pace with all the social networks is no mean feat but if TW free-lancers want to keep working they have no choice. This policy of external learning is being commended to IT employees of this company.

My concern is that there is a generation of people who google everything and I fear for their powers of discrimination.

### Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. [Learn how your comment data is processed.](https://akismet.com/privacy/)

#### Previous post

[Setting a marketing strategy for a Technical Publications Dept](https://www.cherryleaf.com/2010/11/setting-a-marketing-strategy-for-a-technical-publications-dept/)

#### Next post

[Unifying conversation and instruction in business communication](https://www.cherryleaf.com/2010/12/unifying-conversation-and-instruction-in-business-communication/)

#### Browse posts by month

Browse posts by month Select Month  October 2026 (10)  September 2026 (12)  August 2026 (8)  July 2026 (7)  June 2026 (14)  May 2026 (8)  April 2026 (6)  March 2026 (14)  February 2026 (9)  January 2026 (9)  December 2025 (7)  November 2025 (9)  October 2025 (10)  September 2025 (7)  August 2025 (6)  July 2025 (1)  June 2025 (3)  May 2025 (2)  April 2025 (5)  March 2025 (3)  February 2025 (3)  January 2025 (2)  November 2024 (8)  October 2024 (3)  September 2024 (2)  August 2024 (3)  July 2024 (4)  June 2024 (1)  May 2024 (2)  April 2024 (4)  March 2024 (1)  February 2024 (2)  January 2024 (1)  December 2023 (2)  November 2023 (9)  October 2023 (8)  September 2023 (5)  August 2023 (3)  July 2023 (1)  June 2023 (1)  May 2023 (2)  April 2023 (3)  March 2023 (2)  January 2023 (2)  December 2022 (4)  November 2022 (1)  October 2022 (1)  September 2022 (1)  August 2022 (1)  July 2022 (1)  June 2022 (1)  May 2022 (2)  April 2022 (1)  March 2022 (1)  February 2022 (1)  January 2022 (2)  December 2021 (1)  November 2021 (2)  October 2021 (1)  August 2021 (1)  July 2021 (2)  June 2021 (3)  May 2021 (5)  April 2021 (3)  March 2021 (3)  February 2021 (1)  January 2021 (2)  December 2020 (4)  November 2020 (4)  August 2020 (3)  February 2020 (3)  January 2020 (1)  November 2019 (3)  October 2019 (1)  September 2019 (1)  August 2019 (3)  July 2019 (2)  June 2019 (3)  May 2019 (4)  April 2019 (1)  November 2018 (2)  October 2018 (1)  July 2018 (2)  June 2018 (4)  May 2018 (2)  April 2018 (3)  March 2018 (4)  February 2018 (2)  January 2018 (3)  December 2017 (2)  October 2017 (3)  September 2017 (1)  August 2017 (3)  July 2017 (2)  June 2017 (7)  May 2017 (4)  April 2017 (5)  March 2017 (1)  February 2017 (7)  January 2017 (1)  December 2016 (3)  November 2016 (4)  October 2016 (1)  September 2016 (5)  July 2016 (1)  June 2016 (3)  May 2016 (1)  April 2016 (2)  February 2016 (2)  January 2016 (5)  December 2015 (1)  November 2015 (4)  October 2015 (2)  August 2015 (1)  July 2015 (1)  June 2015 (2)  May 2015 (3)  February 2015 (2)  January 2015 (6)  December 2014 (1)  October 2014 (1)  September 2014 (4)  June 2014 (4)  May 2014 (1)  April 2014 (2)  March 2014 (3)  February 2014 (4)  January 2014 (4)  November 2013 (2)  October 2013 (5)  September 2013 (3)  July 2013 (3)  June 2013 (11)  May 2013 (4)  April 2013 (6)  March 2013 (7)  February 2013 (4)  January 2013 (4)  December 2012 (9)  November 2012 (23)  October 2012 (14)  September 2012 (8)  August 2012 (4)  July 2012 (12)  June 2012 (12)  May 2012 (10)  April 2012 (8)  March 2012 (12)  February 2012 (3)  January 2012 (6)  December 2011 (2)  October 2011 (3)  August 2011 (1)  June 2011 (5)  May 2011 (2)  April 2011 (1)  January 2011 (1)  December 2010 (1)  November 2010 (3)  October 2010 (4)  September 2010 (8)  August 2010 (5)  May 2010 (2)  April 2010 (3)  March 2010 (3)  February 2010 (2)  January 2010 (3)  December 2009 (2)  November 2009 (6)  September 2009 (1)  July 2009 (6)  June 2009 (7)  April 2009 (8)  March 2009 (3)  February 2009 (3)  January 2009 (3)  December 2008 (1)  November 2008 (3)  October 2008 (3)  September 2008 (4)  August 2008 (1)  July 2008 (3)  June 2008 (5)  May 2008 (2)  April 2008 (2)  March 2008 (3)  February 2008 (2)  January 2008 (1)  November 2007 (3)  October 2007 (2)  September 2007 (1)  July 2007 (3)  November 2006 (1)  October 2006 (2)  September 2006 (3)  August 2006 (1)  April 2006 (1)  March 2006 (3)

#### Browse posts by category
