--- title: "Untangling the Web navigation conundrum" id: "5751" type: "post" slug: "untangling-the-web-navigation-conundrum" published_at: "2013-06-03T09:46:59+00:00" modified_at: "2013-06-03T09:46:59+00:00" url: "https://www.cherryleaf.com/2013/06/untangling-the-web-navigation-conundrum/" markdown_url: "https://www.cherryleaf.com/2013/06/untangling-the-web-navigation-conundrum.md" excerpt: "There’s been an interesting series of posts recently by Tom Johnson on enabling users to navigate through content in lots of ways (instead of just providing them with a Table of Contents and a search box). It’s the type of..." taxonomy_category: - "content strategy" - "Technical Author" taxonomy_post_tag: - "navigation" - "semantic we" --- There’s been an interesting series of posts recently by Tom Johnson on [enabling users to navigate through content in lots of ways](http://idratherbewriting.com/2013/05/29/can-help-content-have-recognizable-facets/) (instead of just providing them with a Table of Contents and a search box). It’s the type of approach used by sites such as Ravelry.com. Ravelry is a popular social networking site, with over 3 million users, for people who like to knit. It has sophisticated faceted navigation and search capabilities that mean users can search for the ideal knitting project in lots of different way. You can search by type of pattern: cardigan, socks, dress, and so on. You can also search by type of yarn. For example, if you have 4 metres of two ply lace, it will show you the patterns which require that type and length of yarn. In fact, you can search by lots of different factors, such as the type of knitting needles you have, the level of difficulty and the users’ ratings of each patterns. This approach works well if you have content that follows a predictable structure: if your content could be entered by filling in fields in a form or a database. ## What do you do if your content follows a more unpredictable format? The challenges lie with content that follows a less predictable structure, such as reports, user guides, proposals, blog posts, and so on. You often don’t not know what you’re going to include until you start writing. You might also want to include hyperlinks to related content at unpredictable points in the text. ### Structured writing Within the technical writing community, many recommend using semantic, structured writing standards to deal with this issue. Your text looks like roughly like this: [recipe][dish]Fish and Chips[/dish][/recipe] Your text is still categorised and structured, but you have more flexibility over how it is categorised and structured. For example, [DITA](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darwin_Information_Typing_Architecture) has three main simple types of content (Task, Concept and Reference), to which you can add your own specialist types and taxonomies. It’s different way of writing to what people are used to, and many find it hard to adapt. You’ve also got the issue of all the existing content your organisation has. You’d need some or all of your existing content modified to fit your structured format to make it navigable in this way. ### Adding semantic information at page level As an alternative, what many organisations do is leave the sentences and paragraphs in an unstructured, non-semantic, form and add semantic data at the page level (in the technical writing world, we also call a page a “topic”). You can use metadata, through the labels and tagging features in tools such as WordPress and Drupal to add information about each page. In Tom Johnson’s post [Moving Beyond the TOC in Organizing Help Content](http://idratherbewriting.com/2013/05/22/moving-beyond-the-toc-in-organizing-help-content-the-illustrated-edition/) , he includes this graphic to illustrate how you can the use metadata to create dynamic, filtered and faceted navigation links: [http://idratherbewriting.com/2013/05/22/moving-beyond-the-toc-in-organizing-help-content-the-illustrated-edition/](http://idratherbewriting.com/2013/05/22/moving-beyond-the-toc-in-organizing-help-content-the-illustrated-edition/) The advantage of this approach is writers can simply write – they have a familiar authoring environment to work in, and they can leave the tagging and metadata to later (or to someone else). The downside is, it’s difficult to filter or navigate by types of information contained *within* the page. For example, if some of your pages contain warnings or legal disclaimers within the body of text, it might be useful to create a list of all the warnings and disclaimers. You can add metadata to the page saying it contains warning information, but that will only direct you to the page and not to the warning itself. ### A workaround: Embedding pages within pages One way to get around this issue we have implemented for clients, is to embed a page (or a topic) within another page. If your warning is contained in a page (and that page contains metadata identifying it as a warning) that is then embedded into another page, you can then create the lists and filters of the warnings we mentioned above. You probably don’t want these individual warning topics appearing in your main table of contents, so you should locate them in a dedicated folder that’s excluded from your Table of Contents. ## Summary Adding semantic information to your content enables you to provide lots of different ways for your users to filter and navigate the information. However, you need to decide where this semantic structuring occurs. Finding the right balance between having a friendly authoring environment and establishing a usable structure is a challenge many organisations will have to adress in the future. ### Share this: - [Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook](https://www.cherryleaf.com/2013/06/untangling-the-web-navigation-conundrum/?share=facebook) - [Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn](https://www.cherryleaf.com/2013/06/untangling-the-web-navigation-conundrum/?share=linkedin) - [Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp](https://www.cherryleaf.com/2013/06/untangling-the-web-navigation-conundrum/?share=jetpack-whatsapp) - [Share on Bluesky (Opens in new window) Bluesky](https://www.cherryleaf.com/2013/06/untangling-the-web-navigation-conundrum/?share=bluesky) - ### *Related* ### 2 Comments Excellent post, Ellis. Thank you. I think that providing semantic information in addition to a TOC is only adding greater help for folks to find information. I think replacing TOCs without a better way to navigate is a mistake. You still have to meet people where they are, and some still prefer a TOC with a logic flow–even if that flow isn’t sequential. In my personal (hence, limited) experience, semantic information is wonderful for retail items. I love it in Amazon, L.L. Bean, etc. However it’s problematic for nebulous conceptual things like configuring DRBD in Linux. I have no data to back this up. Just a hunch that it would prove difficult–or maybe I’m using such configuration information in a sequential manner that benefits from a structured presentation listed in a TOC. Anyway: thanks for adding to the conversation. Thanks Scot. ### Leave a Reply[Cancel reply](/2013/06/untangling-the-web-navigation-conundrum/#respond) This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. [Learn how your comment data is processed.](https://akismet.com/privacy/) #### Previous post [Why your Web content is like Doctor Who](https://www.cherryleaf.com/2013/06/why-your-web-content-is-like-doctor-who/) #### Next post [How technical content on the Web is turning traditional marketing strategy on its head](https://www.cherryleaf.com/2013/06/how-technical-content-on-the-web-is-turning-the-traditional-marketing-strategy-on-its-head/) #### Browse posts by month Browse posts by month Select Month October 2026 (1) September 2026 (12) August 2026 (8) July 2026 (7) June 2026 (14) May 2026 (8) April 2026 (6) March 2026 (14) February 2026 (9) January 2026 (9) December 2025 (7) November 2025 (9) October 2025 (10) September 2025 (7) August 2025 (6) July 2025 (1) June 2025 (3) May 2025 (2) April 2025 (5) March 2025 (3) February 2025 (3) January 2025 (2) November 2024 (8) October 2024 (3) September 2024 (2) August 2024 (3) July 2024 (4) June 2024 (1) May 2024 (2) April 2024 (4) March 2024 (1) February 2024 (2) January 2024 (1) December 2023 (2) November 2023 (9) October 2023 (8) September 2023 (5) August 2023 (3) July 2023 (1) June 2023 (1) May 2023 (2) April 2023 (3) March 2023 (2) January 2023 (2) December 2022 (4) November 2022 (1) October 2022 (1) September 2022 (1) August 2022 (1) July 2022 (1) June 2022 (1) May 2022 (2) April 2022 (1) March 2022 (1) February 2022 (1) January 2022 (2) December 2021 (1) November 2021 (2) October 2021 (1) August 2021 (1) July 2021 (2) June 2021 (3) May 2021 (5) April 2021 (3) March 2021 (3) February 2021 (1) January 2021 (2) December 2020 (4) November 2020 (4) August 2020 (3) February 2020 (3) January 2020 (1) November 2019 (3) October 2019 (1) September 2019 (1) August 2019 (3) July 2019 (2) June 2019 (3) May 2019 (4) April 2019 (1) November 2018 (2) October 2018 (1) July 2018 (2) June 2018 (4) May 2018 (2) April 2018 (3) March 2018 (4) February 2018 (2) January 2018 (3) December 2017 (2) October 2017 (3) September 2017 (1) August 2017 (3) July 2017 (2) June 2017 (7) May 2017 (4) April 2017 (5) March 2017 (1) February 2017 (7) January 2017 (1) December 2016 (3) November 2016 (4) October 2016 (1) September 2016 (5) July 2016 (1) June 2016 (3) May 2016 (1) April 2016 (2) February 2016 (2) January 2016 (5) December 2015 (1) November 2015 (4) October 2015 (2) August 2015 (1) July 2015 (1) June 2015 (2) May 2015 (3) February 2015 (2) January 2015 (6) December 2014 (1) October 2014 (1) September 2014 (4) June 2014 (4) May 2014 (1) April 2014 (2) March 2014 (3) February 2014 (4) January 2014 (4) November 2013 (2) October 2013 (5) September 2013 (3) July 2013 (3) June 2013 (11) May 2013 (4) April 2013 (6) March 2013 (7) February 2013 (4) January 2013 (4) December 2012 (9) November 2012 (23) October 2012 (14) September 2012 (8) August 2012 (4) July 2012 (12) June 2012 (12) May 2012 (10) April 2012 (8) March 2012 (12) February 2012 (3) January 2012 (6) December 2011 (2) October 2011 (3) August 2011 (1) June 2011 (5) May 2011 (2) April 2011 (1) January 2011 (1) December 2010 (1) November 2010 (3) October 2010 (4) September 2010 (8) August 2010 (5) May 2010 (2) April 2010 (3) March 2010 (3) February 2010 (2) January 2010 (3) December 2009 (2) November 2009 (6) September 2009 (1) July 2009 (6) June 2009 (7) April 2009 (8) March 2009 (3) February 2009 (3) January 2009 (3) December 2008 (1) November 2008 (3) October 2008 (3) September 2008 (4) August 2008 (1) July 2008 (3) June 2008 (5) May 2008 (2) April 2008 (2) March 2008 (3) February 2008 (2) January 2008 (1) November 2007 (3) October 2007 (2) September 2007 (1) July 2007 (3) November 2006 (1) October 2006 (2) September 2006 (3) August 2006 (1) April 2006 (1) March 2006 (3) #### Browse posts by category